Ownership in Software
seth.johnson at realmeasures.dyndns.org
Thu Apr 22 00:56:19 UTC 2004
Axel Schulz wrote:
> Believe it or not I just looked into a book before I get crazy here ;-)
> And now I am certain. A famous professor in this field talks exclusively
> about "ownership".
> But what you explain to me is so sound!!! Now I am completely confused.
> I recognized already that the understanding of ownership differs between
> you (the list members) and me.
It will become clearer and clearer as the tide turns, and all the sheep on
our side will finally recognize that only principle will stand against the
forces trying to screw things for the rest of us in the area of exclusive
rights policy. Richard Stallman is the single most important part of the
information freedom movement, because he has been a rock, staking out the
correct principles for twenty years.
That turn in the tide is very likely to be happening very soon. I predict
that the opening up of the discourse regarding software patents which has
recently been accomplished in the EU by ffii and others, will be the
floodgate for the change.
> > You're talking about information, which is a far cry from property.
> Well, but software is more than that. And if I just hold a authorship in software I would not be able to protect the "excecutable" part of the software, or?
> > Copyright is only a special privilege granted to the way one expresses
> > information, not the information itself.
> If I follow you than copyright (in authorship) and ownership do not fit, right? But a copyright in software works like a right to "ownership", or a means "ownership", doesn't it?
> > Copyright wasn't designed as a property right, quite self-consciously
> > because it participates in the realm of information.
> Yes, but that had to change! Consider my "information on supply" argument.
> After all, I think my freedom argument is still sound. You reject it because of good reason. I stick to it.
> But now I have to sleep!
DRM is Theft! We are the Stakeholders!
New Yorkers for Fair Use
[CC] Counter-copyright: http://realmeasures.dyndns.org/cc
I reserve no rights restricting copying, modification or distribution of
this incidentally recorded communication. Original authorship should be
attributed reasonably, but only so far as such an expectation might hold for
usual practice in ordinary social discourse to which one holds no claim of
More information about the Discussion