is copyright evil? (Re: about warez.at)
David Blane
dbFSF at pigstick.freeserve.co.uk
Sat Oct 20 16:08:27 UTC 2001
On 20 Oct 01, at 14:18, Alessandro Rubini wrote:
> When you listen to music you have all information.
This isn't the case. For music to be libre requires all constituent
sounds to be available and freely sample-able. Also all the
programming (much music is programmed too remember) must be
available and documented. Basically everything possible to make
recreation-from-source and improvement of the sound easy and
legal, so the people don't need cutting-edge analysers (which
presently aren't remotely good enough, AFAIK).
The copyright dilemma becomes clearer if you happen believe that
it is ethical to share and enjoy anything that can be freely copied --
essentially anything digitisable. Whether it's legal or not is then
another question entirely. Not one I can honestly claim to care
about, but it aids discussion for everyone if terms are clarified.
David
More information about the Discussion
mailing list