Constitution violation with the use of GitHub
Paul Boddie
paul at boddie.org.uk
Mon Aug 9 16:32:42 UTC 2021
On Monday, 9 August 2021 12:39:37 CEST André Ockers wrote:
>
> Jacob Hrbek schreef op za 07-08-2021 om 13:44 [+0000]:
> > As mentioned in https://github.com/fsfe/reuse-tool/issues/361 the use
> > of GitHub for REUSE is to my understanding an obvious violation of
> > the constitution of the Free Software Foundation Europe.
> >
> > Thus i elevate the issue here to be discussed for an appropriate
> > action taken by the FSFE or juridistical authority if sufficient
> > action is not taken by the FSFE.
>
> Taking FSFE's mission seriously, a migration to a platform in the Free
> Software-friendly ecosystem would indeed look to be an appropriate step
> to me.
And it's not as if FSFE doesn't have its own hosting platform for
repositories:
https://git.fsfe.org/
But then again, here are the REUSE repositories:
https://git.fsfe.org/reuse
Although I understand the motivation for mirroring repositories on other
hosting platforms, care has to be taken not to drive people onto those
platforms, making them feel obliged to sign up.
I have actually interacted with the REUSE project on GitHub because I
previously had to sign up for GitHub at my employer, and since I was going to
file or comment on issues, it was "convenient" to do things that way. (The
hassle of setting up interaction with GitHub and similar platforms like
Bitbucket means that it is never truly convenient.) But I refuse to create a
personal GitHub account just to interact with projects, and when I last
checked, I was not even allowed to have another account alongside my existing
work account.
The FSFE actually has a reasonable foundation for empowering its supporters
with infrastructure around identity and other services. When I joined the
Fellowship when it was still around, we got smartcards for potential public
key cryptography applications, and one could envisage more being made of such
technologies to help things like secure e-mail proliferate, as well as making
any services more secure and more convenient to use.
Then again, maybe I am just not up-to-date with what people are doing or are
able to do with FSFE infrastructure these days, although this might also mean
that opportunities are being missed to communicate with people likely to be
interested in such matters.
Paul
More information about the Discussion
mailing list