Dear Anne!
On Tue, May 01, 2001 at 01:15:35PM +0200, Anne POSSOZ wrote:
Oh! Maybe some can learn from the others how some european contries are on the language matter. Switzerland has 3 official languages: German, French and Italian (there is a 4th, Romanche, language that is not official)
Romanche is offical as far as I know.
So there, it is absolutely not the case that people speaks "the" official language as there is none... In that sense, it is different from local languages in countries like France or Spain...
There are also different languages in the UK, but almost everyone speaks english. So even, if there are several different languages, one is typically most spread.
Switzerland and Belgium are indeed an exception, I agree. But as far as I know from friends in Belgium and Switzerland these countries already have a lot of problems internally because of that. Belgium seems to be almost split into two different countries with French and Flaemisch. That means, there is no simple solution for such countries. Luckily concerning the FSFE, it will be no problem to participate in whichever mailing list in whichever country you want to be included. So it will probably evolve into a situation, where the German speaking parts of Switzerland will be subscribed to the chapter Germany mailing list, while the French speaking ones will be subscribed to the chapter France one. I see no problem with that. And those who speak all four official languages in Switzerland can then form the chapter Switzerland and decide on a policy for that mailing list. I really don't see a problem here.
And so, there IS a problem to participate in discussions. It is not rare at all that english is the language to communicate, although english is not one of the official languages.
Well, there are two exceptions (two countries) that complicate the situation a bit. But I don't see a real problem.
That was all the reason of my language question. You can also read emails from Marc Schaefer on that matter.
He told me, that there are four official languages in Switzerland.
Bye, Marc _______________________________________________________________________________
email: marc@greenie.net email: m.a.eberhard@aston.ac.uk, web: http://www.aston.ac.uk/~eberhama/
On Wed, 2 May 2001, Marc Eberhard wrote:
On Tue, May 01, 2001 at 01:15:35PM +0200, Anne POSSOZ wrote:
Oh! Maybe some can learn from the others how some european contries are on the language matter. Switzerland has 3 official languages: German, French and Italian (there is a 4th, Romanche, language that is not official)
Romanche is offical as far as I know.
This changed a few years ago: now all 4 languages are national and official. Before, only German, French and Italian where official: you couldn't use Raeto-Rumantsch/Romanche to communicate with the Federal Authorities. Now you can.
Funnily, the official WWW server of the Swiss Confederation Federal Authorities is also available a foreign language which is English :) Also, that WWW server continues to use the old `official' languages meaning and only has some texts available in three languages.
Now, in my opinion, we should start FSFE in the more convenient language which is precizely English, and local chapter languages should be decided on basis of the country's requirements. In addition, nothing prevents a local chapter from using one or more of the translations made by other local chapters.