In summary:
o The firm philosophical stance Georg wishes from FSFE members ought to be concerned with high, broad and long aims for humanity, and encompass more than software programs.
To what extent? To the extent of all things 'digital'? To the extent of information, content, etc? Or beyond that?
o Encourage the creation of GNU sisters, under that broad philosophical umbrella of FSF(E), for music, books, video, and whatever else is webbable.
I think all that helps to do is muddy the waters a bit, really. Obviously, FSFers are always going to have their own opinions, and most of the time these opinions are probably going to be anti-patent, anti-this and anti-that. I think the importance of Free Software is much greater than that of Free Music, for example, and needs a separate emphasis.
o Keep implementation details like the GPL out of FSF(E).
I would argue stuff like the GPL is the ultimate expression of the philosophy, and is very much the most important tenet ;)) Since the GPL is the 'action' end of what the FSF does, it has to be the 'master template' for the philosophy, in a way, actions speak louder than words, yadda yadda :)
o For reasons I hope I've made clear, don't have a gnu on the FSFE logo.
I'm sure a lot of people would agree that the need for Free Software is not equal to the need for a Free Unix. But, Free Unix is where things are at right now, and you have to think about now as well as the future. By concentrating on Free (not :) Unix, i.e. GNU, we're delivering on our promises in the short term but not cutting off what can happen in the long term.
Interesting thoughts though ;)
Cheers,
Alex.