[FSFE PR][DE] Cyber Resilience Act & Free Software: Parliament waters down its own position

[press at fsfe.org]

 = Cyber Resilience Act & Free Software: Parliament waters down its own position =

[ Online lesen: https://fsfe.org/news/2023/news-20230719-01.de.html ]

The European Parliament today voted on its position on the Cyber
Resilience Act (CRA). While the position improves on the Commission's
exemption to protect Free Software, it fails to introduce a proper
protection . We call on the institutions to put the burden of liability
only on those who significantly financially benefit from the market,
while protecting developers and non-profit work.

The Commission’s proposal to exclude Free Software “outside the course
of a commercial activity” would fail to address a large part of software
that will not be covered but is deployed. At the same time, smaller and
non-profit projects would be harmed as they would have to bear major
costs.

Therefore we have already proposed a solution that will lead to more
security while safeguarding Free Software:

1. Liability should be shifted to those *deploying* Free Software
   instead of those *developing* Free Software and

2. Those who significantly financially benefit from this deployment
   should make sure the software becomes CE-compliant

While the Internal Market and Consumer Protection Committee (IMCO), a
committee for opinion in CRA, backed our demand and voted for the
protection of Free Software developers in the Cyber Resilience Act, the
Committee on Industry, Research and Energy (ITRE) introduced less far
reaching protections with today's vote. Regular corporate donations or
contributions by corporate employees to a project could turn non-profit
work into a “commercial activity”, and thus lead to liability.

/Alexander Sander, FSFE Senior Policy Consultant explains:/ "With
today's vote, the EU Parliament has watered down its own position.
Placing the burden of liability on small or non-profit entities that
rely on regular donations would harm the Free Software and thus society
and business alike. Due to the lack of funding and resources to go
through the proposed procedures to become CE compliant, some of these
projects might have to stop completely. We call on the institutions to
find a compromise that safeguards the Free Software ecosystem while
shifting liability to those who significantly financially benefit from
the deployment” /./   Interinstitutional negotiations will start start
soon and should be concluded this year if possible. You can read more
here [1].

 1: https://fsfe.org/news/2023/news-20230323-01.de.html

  == Über die Free Software Foundation Europe ==

  Die Free Software Foundation Europe ist ein gemeinnütziger Verein, der
  Menschen im selbstbestimmten Umgang mit Technik unterstützt. Software
  beeinflusst sämtliche Bereiche unseres Lebens. Es ist wichtig, dass
  diese Technik uns hilft, statt uns einzuschränken. Freie Software gibt
  allen das Recht, Programme für jeden Zweck zu verwenden, zu verstehen,
  zu verbreiten und zu verbessern. Diese Freiheiten stärken andere
  Grundrechte wie die Redefreiheit, die Pressefreiheit und das Recht auf
  Privatsphäre.

  Die FSFE hilft Menschen und Organisationen dabei, zu verstehen, wie
  Freie Software zu Freiheit, Transparenz und Selbstbestimmung beiträgt.
  Sie stärkt Nutzerrechte, indem sie Hürden für den Einsatz Freier
  Software beseitigt, ermutigt Menschen zum Einsatz und zur Entwicklung
  Freier Software, und stellt Ressourcen für alle bereit, die Freie
  Software in Europa voranbringen wollen.

  https://fsfe.org